Planning Objection Guide

Objecting to a Retention Planning Application in Ireland

What retention permission is, why the 5-week window still applies when the work is already built, what section 34(12) means, and how to write your objection.

Last updated: 7 November 2026  ·  Applies to every Irish planning authority

A retention application asks the council to approve development that has already been built without planning permission, and you can object to it in the same way as any other application: a written submission with the €20 fee that reaches the council within 5 weeks of it receiving the application.

People often assume that because the work is already there, it is too late or pointless to object. The rules we read do not say that. Article 29 sets the period for a submission on "a planning application" and, in the text we read, makes no separate rule for retention applications, and section 34(12C) of the Planning and Development Act 2000 applies section 34 to a retention application. The council weighs it on planning grounds like any other, with the extra limits in section 34(12) described below.

What is a retention application?

Retention permission is permission sought after the work has been done. The Office of the Planning Regulator's planning leaflet explains that a person who has carried out unauthorised development, for example through a genuine mistake, may apply for permission to retain it; that this should not be relied on to avoid getting permission first; that retention may be refused or may come with costly modifications; and that the application fee is three times the fee for an application made before the work starts. Cork County Council says the same on its enforcement page.

The Act allows it: section 34(12C) says an application may be made for the retention of unauthorised development and that section 34 applies to it. "Unauthorised development" means unauthorised works (including building an unauthorised structure) or an unauthorised use (section 2). Look for the word "retention" in the description of the application on the council's planning register.

It is already built: does the 5-week window still apply?

The most important thing to know first
You have 5 weeks beginning on the date the council received the planning application. That day counts as day 1, so your last day is 34 days after the received date. The days from 24 December to 1 January (inclusive) are not counted, so a period that includes them ends nine days later. A submission that arrives after the 5 weeks is returned to you with the fee and cannot be considered (Article 29(1) and (3) of the Planning and Development Regulations 2001; section 251 of the Planning and Development Act 2000). Find the date of receipt on the council's planning register: it is the date the clock runs from.

The fee is €20, paid to the council (Article 168 and Schedule 10), and anyone other than the applicant can make a submission. Your submission must be in writing and give your name and an address for correspondence (Article 29(1)(b)); Fingal, Louth and Dún Laoghaire-Rathdown also ask for the application reference number. The council must acknowledge it in writing (Article 29(2)); keep the acknowledgement, because you need it if you appeal. The box at the top of this page works out your last day if you enter the date the council received the application.

What the council cannot grant: section 34(12)

Section 34(12) says the council must refuse to consider an application to retain unauthorised development where it decides that an environmental impact assessment or an appropriate assessment was required, or is required, for the development. If it refuses to consider an application on that basis it must return the application and any fee to the applicant and give its reasons (section 34(12B)). The Office of the Planning Regulator's leaflet explains the logic: under the EU directives those assessments would have been needed had the application been made before the unauthorised work took place.

Section 34(12A) deems two kinds of development not to have required, and not to require, a determination on whether an environmental impact assessment is required: development within the curtilage of a dwelling house for a purpose incidental to enjoying it as a dwelling, and modifications to the exterior of a building. Our reading is that, for ordinary house works, the environmental impact assessment limb is therefore unlikely to be the issue, but that deeming rule does not mention appropriate assessment.

The council decides whether either assessment was required. If you believe one was, say so in your submission, give your reasons and ask the council to consider whether section 34(12) applies. If you are unsure, ask the council.

Grounds for objecting to a retention application

Not planning grounds: personal dislikes, grievances or opinions (Fingal, Louth and the Office of the Planning Regulator), and boundary disputes and similar questions that are better settled by other legal means (the Office of the Planning Regulator's example is boundary disputes). Do not make allegations about the applicant: Dublin City and Fingal warn that comments alleging something against a named or identifiable person may be treated as defamatory and the writer may be sued directly. We found no official page that settles whether property value or loss of a view counts, so we do not build a letter around them.

Your name and address are published with your submission (Dublin City says telephone numbers and email addresses are redacted).

A retention application does not stop enforcement

Section 162(3) of the Act says no enforcement action under that Part (including an application under section 160) is stayed or withdrawn because of a retention application or the grant of permission on it. South Dublin, Cork County and Clare say the same on their enforcement pages. If you want the council to look at unauthorised development separately from a planning application, councils run an enforcement process of their own (Clare's page describes the complaint, warning letter and enforcement notice steps); check your own council's page. That is a different route from a submission.

How to write the submission

  1. Top of the letter: the council, the application reference number, your name and the address where the council should write to you.
  2. Say where you are in relation to the site, and what has been built.
  3. Choose two or three grounds that really apply and describe the effect you can see today, with rooms, distances and heights.
  4. Cite the development plan policy by number, alongside the section 34(2)(a) test.
  5. If relevant, raise section 34(12) and your reasons for thinking an assessment was required.
  6. Ask for a specific outcome: refusal or, if the council is minded to grant, conditions.
I object to the application to retain the [describe what was built] at [site address]. The [window/structure] that has already been built looks directly into the rear garden and bedroom of [your address] at a distance of about [X] metres, and its height of [Z] metres along our boundary casts shadow on our kitchen window in the afternoon. This conflicts with Policy [number] of the [County] Development Plan on residential amenity. I also ask the council to consider whether section 34(12) of the Planning and Development Act 2000 applies, because [reason, if you have one]. I ask the council to refuse permission for retention or, if it is minded to grant, to attach conditions on the height and the glazing.
Ready to object?

Draft your objection to the retention application

Answer a few questions about the application and the work that has been built. PlanningLetter drafts a letter from your answers; the preview is free before you pay anything.

Write My Objection Letter

Free preview  ·  €9.99 to download the PDF  ·  You submit it yourself  ·  Refund policy

After you lodge

What PlanningLetter does, and does not do
You answer questions about the application and how it affects you, and PlanningLetter drafts an objection letter from your answers. The preview is free; the PDF costs €9.99 once. It is a draft for you to read and correct. You then submit it to the council yourself and pay the council's €20 fee directly; we do not submit anything for you, we cannot predict whether an objection will succeed, and we are not solicitors or planning consultants. PlanningLetter is independent of every council and of An Coimisiún Pleanála. See how it works.

Official sources used

The text of the Planning and Development Act 2000 used here is the Law Reform Commission's revised version, updated to 12 August 2026; that page says later changes have not yet been added by its editors, and the Planning and Development Act 2024 will replace parts of the 2000 Act when it is commenced. The regulations text is the Department of Housing's unofficial consolidation to 30 June 2024. Rules and fees can change, so confirm the current position with your council before you lodge anything.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Objections must reach the council within 5 weeks of the application being received, with the €20 fee.